“New, unadopted property.” The Hitchin MP, Alistair Strathern, pointed. Then he gestured to a constructing web site the place diggers had been enthusiastically attending to work. “New property that can be unadopted… Unadopted property… Unadopted property.” Through the 20-minute drive from Shefford city centre to Hitchin Station, we handed at the least six examples of the phenomenon Strathern had invited me to his constituency, which straddles the Bedfordshire-Hertfordshire border, to discover: new-build housing estates their councils have refused to undertake.
A lot has been written about leasehold, the peculiarly British “feudal” system by which homebuyers personal a property however not the land it sits on, leaving them chargeable for spiralling floor lease and administration charges. After a long time of advocacy, some enhancements had been made underneath the Conservatives in final 12 months’s Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act, and Labour has promised to go additional with protections for leaseholders on this parliament.
However even when new-build houses are offered with the freehold, hidden prices can sneak in. Generally known as “fleecehold” housing, the estates Strathern identified are these the place the duty for sustaining the roads, avenue lighting, drainage and communal areas has not been adopted by the council, because it deems improvement to not have been accomplished to a excessive sufficient commonplace. Till a improvement is adopted, the residents should pay for the providers the council would often present, along with council tax, through yearly charges paid to non-public administration firms.
The charges themselves could not sound giant – £200-£300 a 12 months. Or, at the least, that’s the extent at which they begin out. At a brand new property I visited, charges had been hiked by 41 per cent in a 12 months, with obscure explanations. Calls and emails to the administration firm went largely unanswered; correspondence was restricted to scarily worded “remaining demand” letters. If homeowners refuse to pay, administration firms can go direct to their lender to have the costs added to their mortgage, tanking the proprietor’s credit standing. Residents I met spoke of discovering it inconceivable to find out what they had been paying for, or to carry the administration firm accountable for the work it was – or wasn’t – finishing up.
Fleecehold is now the norm throughout the nation. Whereas councils used to undertake new estates, the Competitors and Markets Authority has discovered that 80 per cent of latest houses constructed by the 11 largest builders in 2021-22 had been offered underneath the fleecehold system, with £260m in property administration fees paid out in 2022 alone. There are tales of homeowners being assured their property could be adopted as a formality, solely to nonetheless be paying charges a decade on. In the meantime, the federal government is pushing by means of planning reform to satisfy its goal of 1.5 million new houses by the tip of this parliament.
The issue might not be as visceral as the problems with construct high quality that homeowners of new-builds usually face: cracked partitions, dodgy plumbing, damp and mildew. However the two are inextricably linked. Each proprietor I spoke to about fleecehold fees additionally had a horror story of how their “dream residence” had was a nightmare of building faults that builders had been reluctant to rectify. One confirmed me a brimming lever-arch folder of his correspondence with the developer – 200 pages in 20 months.
The query is considered one of accountability. When issues go fallacious, whose job is it to repair them? What occurs in the event that they fail to take action? And the way are they seemingly in a position to cost what they like, with no cap on prices or any obligation to point out how the cash is spent?
You may think the council would step in. However, as I discovered in Hitchin, cash-strapped native authorities have little incentive to make sure developments are constructed to plain, as adopting them means adopting extra prices. The builders, in the meantime, have little incentive to come back again to finish repairs as soon as the homes have been offered. Strathern, who labored on the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Invoice committee, is hoping to vary this and has launched a debate in parliament on making certain new estates are adopted on schedule. However it’s onerous to repair an issue most individuals don’t even know exists till after they’ve purchased their houses.
Passing the accountability buck will be an artwork type. In Shefford, I visited Previous Bridge Manner: a 220m stretch of highway by means of an industrial park connecting an property of some 1,000 houses to the centre of city and a Morrisons. I stood there for ten minutes watching continuous site visitors navigate a maze of potholes six inches deep. Central Bedfordshire Council says this isn’t its duty, because it doesn’t really personal that a part of the highway. Who does personal it’s an open query: the corporate answerable for it was liquidated in 2024, leaving it successfully ownerless. However I observed double yellow traces alongside the kerbside. I requested the council if it was issuing parking fines for a highway it claimed it had no duty for, nevertheless it didn’t supply a solution.
A council that received’t undertake a thoroughfare utilized by 1000’s of individuals is unlikely to undertake estates full of latest houses. Strathern described each conditions as “hollowed-out councils retreating from the general public realm”. To me, they resembled what the satirical science-fiction creator Douglas Adams as soon as termed a Any individual Else’s Drawback subject, a means of concealing inconvenient issues that utilises “individuals’s pure predisposition to not see something they don’t wish to, weren’t anticipating, or can’t clarify”. For residents positioned in fleecehold limbo the problems of rising charges and the dearth of accountability are inconceivable to disregard. For everybody else, they’re Any individual Else’s Drawback.
[See also: GMB chief Gary Smith: “Oil and gas is not the enemy”]